01
Reach out
Email us what you’ve got: sport, era, and roughly how much of it there is. Photos help a lot if you have them. Email is quickest, but you’re welcome to call.
Sell your collection
Turn your collection into a fair offer.
A shoebox from the closet or a collection you’ve kept for decades, we’d like to see it. We buy vintage from before 1980 and modern from 1980 to today.
Four sports, early 1900s through this year’s rookies. You’ll hear back within 72 hours.
How it works
Four steps, no pressure
The same process whether it’s one card or a whole room. You can stop at any step.
02
We take a look
Alan and Matt go through condition and check what cards like yours actually sold for recently. Larger collections may need an in-person look.
03
A fair offer
No pressure and honest assessment. If you want to know how we got to the number, ask and we’ll walk you through it card by card.
04
Get paid, or consign
Sell outright, or have us list your cards on eBay. We’ll tell you which is the best fit.
What we buy
Four sports, early 1900s through this year’s rookies
Baseball
Basketball
Football
Hockey
Pre-1980
Vintage
Anything before 1980. Stars, commons, partial sets, oddball issues, if it’s old we want to see it, and condition matters less than people expect.
1980–today
Modern
Rookies, inserts, numbered parallels, and current-year product. The exception is bulk commons from the ’80s and ’90s, see below.
PSA · BGS · SGC · CGC
Graded slabs
Bring the cert numbers if you have them and we can give you a read before you drive anywhere.
Boxes to whole rooms
Full collections & estates
If someone in the family collected for decades and you don’t know where to start, reach out and we’ll help you sort through it.
Signed items
Memorabilia & autographs
Signed balls, photos and equipment alongside cards. Tell us what authentication came with it, if any.
One card is fine
Singles & small lots
A single card gets the same attention as a large collection, that isn’t a slogan, it’s just how Alan and Matt work.
72 hrs
Or less to hear back, every time. If you haven’t heard from us by then, write or call again. Something went wrong on our end.
What we don’t buy
The short list, so nobody wastes a trip
Bulk commons, 1980s & ’90s
Not right now.
We’re well stocked, so we aren’t buying these in bulk at the moment. Not a judgment on your cards. We just can’t move them, and we’d rather tell you that than make an offer that isn’t worth your time.
Stars, rookies and inserts from those years are a different story. Those we’ll still look at.
When it’s a maybe
Ask anyway.
What we’re stocked on changes month to month, and a card we passed on in the spring might be one we want in the fall. A short email costs you nothing and we’ll give you a straight answer.
Consignment
Would rather list than sell outright?
We offer competitive consignment rates for collectors who’d rather have us list and sell their cards on eBay than sell everything to us directly. We handle the photos, listings, questions, and shipping. Reach out and we’ll walk you through how it works and what we charge.
Tell us what you’ve got
Sport, era, rough size. That’s enough to start.
Add a photo or two if you have them and we can give you a real answer, usually the same week. Thanks for thinking of us.