01
Show us what you’d consign
Email a list or some photos. We’ll tell you which cards are worth listing individually, which are better as a lot, and which honestly aren’t worth either of our time.
Services · Consignment
We list it.
Some cards are worth more sold one at a time than sold as a lot. If you’d rather not deal with photos, listings, buyer questions and shipping, we’ll run it on our eBay store and agree on payout terms with you before anything is listed.
Track record12,000+Items sold through the same store your cards go on.
Feedback100%Positive, which is what gets your card sold.
UnsoldBy agreementWe’ll discuss the time frame before anything goes up.
How it works
You hand off the cards. We do the rest.
02
We agree on terms first
Any reserve or minimum you want on a card, and how long we’ll let something sit before we talk about lowering the price. Nothing gets listed until you’ve given your approval.
03
We photograph, list, and answer for it
Your cards go up on the same store that’s moved 12,000+ items at 100% positive feedback. Condition gets described accurately, which helps build trust with potential buyers.
04
It sells, you get paid
We pack and ship it, handle any issue the buyer raises, and send your share. Anything that doesn’t sell comes back to you.
Which one fits
Two ways to sell.
Consigning can net more for cards with real value, but can take longer to sell. Selling outright is faster and puts cash in hand today. Here’s an honest look at both, so you can pick what fits.
We handle
Everything after you hand them over
- Photographing every card
- Writing the listing and describing condition
- Pricing against recent sold comps
- Answering buyer questions
- Packing, shipping, and tracking
- Anything that goes wrong after the sale
Good fit when
Consigning puts more in your pocket
- You’d rather wait for the right buyer
- You don’t have the time to list it yourself
Sell outright instead when
A flat payout is the better call
- You want the money now, not in a few months
- You’d rather it be done sooner than later
If that’s you, we’ll say so. Here’s how selling to us works.
The split
Here’s exactly what you take home.
The payout scales with the final sale price, shipping included. Whatever tier your card lands in, it’s the same rate for everyone, agreed before anything is listed.
| Final sale price | Payout |
|---|---|
| Under $10 | $3.50 flat fee |
| $10 – $49.99 | 70% minus $1 |
| $50 – $99.99 | 70% |
| $100 – $499.99 | 72% |
| $500 – $999.99 | 73% |
| $1,000 – $2,499.99 | 75% |
| $2,500 – $4,999.99 | 77% |
| $5,000 – $9,999.99 | 80% |
| $10,000 and up | 85% |
*Final sale price includes shipping. Rates updated and effective September 2026.
Still deciding
Not sure whether to consign or sell?
Tell us what you’ve got and we’ll give you our honest read on which one puts more money in your pocket, including when the answer is “sell it outright.” Either way, we appreciate you asking.